%0 Journal Article
%T On
%A Alessandro Antonelli
%A Alessandro Veccia
%A Andrea Mari
%A Andrea Minervini
%A Carlotta Palumbo
%A Claudio Simeone
%A Lance J Hampton
%A Pierluigi Bove
%A Riccardo Autorino
%A Riccardo Bertolo
%A Simone Francavilla
%J Urologia Journal
%@ 1724-6075
%D 2019
%R 10.1177/0391560319847847
%X The debate on the pros and cons of robot-assisted partial nephrectomy performed with (on-clamp) or without (off-clamp) renal artery clamping is ongoing. The aim of this meta-analysis is to summarize the available evidence on the comparative studies assessing the outcomes of these two approaches. A systematic review of the literature on PubMed, ScienceDirectˋ, and Embaseˋ was conducted according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses Statement (PRISMA). Only comparative and case-control studies were submitted to full-text assessment and meta-analysis. RevMan 5.3 software was used. From the initial retrieval of 1937 studies, 15 fulfilling inclusion criteria were selected and provided 2075 patients for analysis (702 off-clamp, 1373 on-clamp). Baseline tumor＊s features showed a significant difference in size (weighted mean difference: 每0.58ˋcm; 95% confidence interval: [每1.06, 每0.10]; pˋ=ˋ0.02) and R.E.N.A.L. score (weighted mean difference: 每0.53; 95% confidence interval: [每0.81, 每0.25]; pˋ=ˋ0.0002), but not in the exophytic property, the location, and the PADUA score. Pooled analysis revealed shorter operative time (pˋ=ˋ0.02) and higher estimated blood loss (pˋ=ˋ0.0002) for the off-clamp group. Overall complication and transfusion rates were similar, while higher major complication rate was observed in the on-clamp approach (5.6% vs 1.9%, pˋ=ˋ0.03). No differences in oncological outcomes were found. Finally, functional outcomes (assessed by estimated glomerular filtration rate at early postoperative, 3ˋmonth, 6ˋmonth, and last available follow-up) were not statistically different. This meta-analysis shows that off-clamp robot-assisted partial nephrectomy is reserved to smaller renal masses. Under such conditions, no differences with the on-clamp approach emerged
%K Off-clamp
%K on-clamp
%K robot-assisted partial nephrectomy
%K hilar control
%K kidney cancer
%U https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0391560319847847