Livestock production is a key income source in eastern Africa, and 80% of the total agricultural land is used for livestock herding. Hence, ecological and socio-economically sustainable rangeland management is crucial. Our study aimed at selecting operational economic, environmental and social sustainability indicators for three main pastoral (P), agro-pastoral (AP), and landless intensive (LI) small scale livestock production systems for use in sustainability assessment in Ethiopia. Quantitative and qualitative data were collected through grey literature and semi-structured interviews, assessing livestock and feed resources, production technology, land tenure, financial and gender issues. Our results suggested that feed shortages (FS) are directly related to grazing pressure (G) and inversely related to grass recovery rates (R). According to our indicators, AP was the most sustainable while P and LI were only conditionally sustainable production systems. 93% of 82 interviewees claimed that private land ownership was the best land tenure incentive for efficient rangeland management. Farmers perceived Prosopis juliflora expansion, sporadic rainfall, and disease infestation as the most significant causes for decreasing livestock productivity. Landless intensive farmers had the highest equality in income distribution (Gini Index: GI = 0.4), followed by P and AP (each with a GI = 0.5). Neither educational background nor income seemed to determine grazing species conservation efforts. We claimed that sustainability indicators are valuable tools to highlight shortcomings and strengths of the three main livestock production systems and help with future livestock management in Ethiopia. Selecting suitable indicators, however, is crucial as data requirements and availability can vary across livestock systems.
References
[1]
Jahnke, H.E. Livestock Production Systems and Livestock Development in Tropical Africa; Kieler Wissenschaftsverlag Vauk: Kiel, Germany, 1982; pp. 1–5.
[2]
Food and Agricultural Organisation (FAO). FAOSTAT. 1999. Available online: http://apps.fao.org/cgi-bin/nph.db.pl (accessed on 15 September 2012).
[3]
Institute of Biodiversity Conservation (IBC). Available online: http://www.ibc.gov.et/biodiversity/components-of-biodiversity/animal-species-diversity (accessed on 30 August 2012).
[4]
Central Statistical Agency (CSA). Agricultural Sample Survey Report on Livestock, Poultry, and Beehive Populations. CSA: Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 1999; Volume II, p. 280.
[5]
Hansen, J.W. Is agricultural sustainability a useful concept? Agric. Syst. 1996, 50, 117–143, doi:10.1016/0308-521X(95)00011-S.
[6]
International Livestock Research Institute(ILRI). Livestock Policy Analysis; ILRI Training Manual 2; ILRI: Nairobi, Kenya, 1995; p. 249.
[7]
Benin, S.; Ehui, S.; Pender, J. Policies for livestock development in the Ethiopian highlands. Environ. Dev. Sustain. 2003, 5, 491–510, doi:10.1023/A:1025737315629.
[8]
Deacon, R.T. Deforestation and the rule of law in a cross-section of countries. Land Econ. 1994, 70, 414–443, doi:10.2307/3146638.
[9]
Department for International Development (DFID); Pretty, J. Agricultural Sustainability. Assessing Sustainability; Agriculture and Natural Resources Team, UK Department for International Development (DFID)/University of Essex Press: Colchester, UK, 2004; p. 8.
[10]
Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO). Contributions of Smallholder Farmers and Pastoralists to the Development, Use and Conservation of Animal Genetic Resources. Information Document 4, Available online: http://www.fao.org/docrep/meeting/021/am216e.pdf (accessed on 2 November 2013).
[11]
World Commission on Environment and Development. Our Common Future; Oxford University Press: Oxford, UK, 1987; p. 383.
[12]
Seré, C.; Steinfeld, H.; Groeneworld, J. World Livestock Production Systems: Current Status, Issues and Trends; FAO Animal Production and Health Paper 127; FAO: Rome, Italy, 1996; p. 98.
[13]
de Leeuw, P.N.; Thorpe, W. Low Input Cattle Production Systems in Tropical Africa: An Analysis of Actual and Potential Cow-Calf Productivity. In Proceedings of the All African Conference on Annual Agriculture Conference, Pretoria, South Africa, 1–4 April 1996; pp. 2–4.
[14]
Blench, R.M. You Can’t Go Home Again. Pastoralism in the New Millenium, 2001, pp. 6–40. Available online: http://www.org.odi.uk/staff/r.blench (accessed on 13 March 2013).
[15]
Nkurumwa, A.O.; Mwangi, J.G.; Kathuri, N.J. Livelihood Diversification and Enhanced Food Security through Agro-Pastoralism: Socio-Cultural and Other Challenges among Maasai Pastoralists of Narok North District of Kenya. In Proceedings of Second RUFORUM Biennial Meeting, Entebbe, Uganda, 20–24 September 2010; pp. 1633–1636.
[16]
Gerber, P.; Mooney, H.A.; Dijkman, J.; Tarawali, S.; Haan, C.D. Chapter 1. Introduction. In Livestock in a Changing Landscape. Experiences and Regional Perspectives; Island Press: Washington, DC, USA, 2010; Volume 2, p. 7.
[17]
Bourn, D.; Maitima, J.; Motsamai, B. Livestock and the Environment. In Livestock and Wealth Creation: Improving the Husbandry of Livestock Kept by the Poor in Developing Countries; Kitalyi, A.J., Jayasuriya, N., Owen, E., Smith, T., Eds.; Nottingham University Press: Nottingham, UK, 2005; pp. 145–165.
[18]
Canagasaby, D.; Morton, J.; Rischkoowsky, B.; Thomas, D. Livestock Systems. In Livestock and Wealth Creation: Improving the Husbandry of Livestock Kept by Resource Poor People in Developing Countries; Kitalyi, A.J., Jayasuriya, N., Owen, E., Smith, T., Eds.; Nottingham University Press: Nottingham, UK, 2005; pp. 29–52.
[19]
Steinfeld, H.; M？ki-Hokkonen, J. A classification of livestock production systems. World Anim. Rev. 1995, 84/85, 83–94.
[20]
Drexhage, J.; Murphy, D. Sustainable Development: From Brundtland to Rio 2012. In Proceedings of the First Meeting of High Level Panel on Global Sustainability, New York, NY, USA, 19 September 2010; pp. 6–12.
[21]
Dumanski, J.; Smyth, A.J.; Spendjian, G.; Swift, M.J.; Thornton, P.K. FESLM: An In ternational Framework for Evaluating Sustainable Land Management. In World Soil Resources Report 73; Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations: Rome, Italy, 1993; pp. 6–37.
[22]
Bell, S.; Morse, S. Measuring Sustainability: Learning from Doing; Earthscan Publications: London, UK, 2003; pp. 3–48.
[23]
Smith, C.S.; McDonald, G.T. Assessing the sustainability of agriculture at the planning stage. J. Environ. Manag. 1998, 52, 15–37, doi:10.1006/jema.1997.0162.
[24]
Saradon, J.S. El Desarollo y Uso de Indicadores Para Evaluar la Sustentabilidad de los Agroecosystemas. In Agroecologia. El camino Hacia una Agricultural Sustentable. Edicions Cientificas Americanas; Scribd: San Francisco, CA, USA, 2002; pp. 393–414.
[25]
Braat, L. The Predictive Meaning of Sustainability Indicators. In Search of Indicators of Sustainable Development; Onno, K., Verbruggen, H., Eds.; Kluwer Academic Publisher: Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 1991; pp. 57–70.
[26]
Simon, D. Sustainable development. Theoretical construct or attainable goal? Environ. Conserv. 1989, 16, 41–48, doi:10.1017/S0376892900008493.
[27]
Senanayake, R. Sustainable agriculture: Definition and parameters for measurement. J. Sustain. Agric. 1991, 1, 6–30, doi:10.1300/J064v01n04_03.
[28]
Lynam, J.K.; Herdt, R.W. Sense and sustainability: Sustainability as an objective in international agricultural research. Agric. Econ. 1989, 3, 381–398, doi:10.1016/0169-5150(89)90010-8.
[29]
Chen, S.K. The establishment of evaluation and indices system for Chinese sustainable development. World Environ. 2000, 1, 1–9.
[30]
Zehn, L.; Routray, J.T. Operational indicators for measuring agricultural sustainability in developing countries. Environ. Manag. 2002, 32, 34–44.
[31]
Pretty, J.N. Regenerating Agriculture: Policies and Practice for Sustainability and Self-Reliance; Earthscan Publications Ltd.: London, UK, 1995; pp. 8–12.
[32]
Monteith, J.L. Can sustainability be quantified? Indian J. Dryland Res. Dev. 1990, 5, 1–15.
[33]
Ikerd, J. Two related but distinctly different concepts: Organic farming and sustainable agriculture. Small Farm. Today 1993, 10, 30–31.
[34]
Webster, P. The challenge of sustainability at the farm level: Presidential address. J.Agric. Econ. 1999, 50, 371–387, doi:10.1111/j.1477-9552.1999.tb00888.x.
[35]
Torquebiau, E. Are tropical agro forestry gardens sustainable? Agric. Hum. Value. 1992, 9, 11–19.
[36]
Gryseels, G. The Role of Livestock in the Generation of Smallholder Farm Income in Two Vertisol Areas of the Central Ethiopian Highlands. In Management of Vertisols in Sub-Saharan Africa: Proceedings of a Conference Held at the International Livestock Centre for Africa (ILCA), Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 31 August–4 September 1987; Jutzi, S.C., Haque, I., McIntire, J., Stares, J.E.S., Eds.; International Livestock Center for Africa (ILCA): Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 1988; pp. 345–358.
[37]
Conway, G.R. The properties of agro-ecosystems. Agric. Syst. 1987, 24, 95–117, doi:10.1016/0308-521X(87)90056-4.
[38]
Marten, G. Productivity, stability, sustainability, equality and autonomy as properties for agro ecosystems assessment. Agric. Syst. 1988, 26, 291–316, doi:10.1016/0308-521X(88)90046-7.
[39]
Kaine, G.W.; Tozer, P.R. Stability, resilience and sustainability in pasture base grazing systems. Agric. Syst. 2005, 83, 27–48, doi:10.1016/j.agsy.2004.03.001.
[40]
Central Statistical Agency (CSA). Statistical Abstract; Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia: Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 2007.
[41]
Melka-Werer Livestock Research Center. Meteorological Division; Ethiopian Agricultural Research Organization (EARO): Amibara, Ethiopia, 2011.
[42]
Getachew, K.N. Among the Pastoral Afar in Ethiopia: Tradition, Continuity and Socioeconomic Change; International Books: Dublin, Germany, 2001.
[43]
Tesfaye, G. Ecological diversity and dominant species of desert and semi desert ecosystem in the Afar Region. Biodivers. Newsl. 2002, 1, 11–14.
[44]
Food and Agricultural Organisation (FAO). How to Feed the World by 2050. In Proceedings of FAO Expert Meeting, Rome, Italy, 24–26 June 2009; p. 2.
[45]
Little, P.D.; Smith, K.; Cellarius, B.A.; Coppock, D.L.; Barrett, C. Avoiding disaster: Diversification and risk management among East African herders. Dev. Chang. 2001, 32, 401–433.
[46]
Desta, S.; Coppock, D.L. Pastoralism under pressure: Tracking system change in Southern Ethiopia. Hum. Ecol. 2004, 32, 465–486, doi:10.1023/B:HUEC.0000043516.56037.6b.
[47]
Pedersen, J.; Benjaminsen, T. One leg or two? Food security and pastoralism in the Northern Sahel. Hum. Ecol. 2008, 36, 43–57, doi:10.1007/s10745-007-9136-3.
[48]
Mueller, S. Evaluating the Sustainability of Agriculture: The Case of the Reventado River Watershed in Costa Rica. In European University Studies Series 5; Peter Lang GmbH: Frankfurt, Germany, 1997; p. 223.
[49]
Praneetvatakul, S.; Janekarnkij, P.; Prayoonwong, K. Assessing the Sustainability of Agriculture. In Case of Mae Chaem Catchment, Northern Thailand; Pergamon: Oxford, UK, 2001; pp. 103–109.
[50]
Thai Department of Land Development (DLD). Framework of Evaluation of Sustainable Land Management—A Case Study: Ban Pha Duea, Mae Fha Louang Districts, Chiangrai Province, Thailand; Thai Department of Land Development (DLD): Bangkok, Thailand, 1998.
[51]
Tisdell, C. Economic indicators to assess the sustainability of conservation farming projects: An evaluation. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 1996, 57, 117–131, doi:10.1016/0167-8809(96)01017-1.
[52]
Rohde, R.F.; Moleele, N.M.; Mphale, M.; Allsopp, N.; Chanda, R.; Hoffman, M.T.; Magole, L.; Young, E. Dynamics of grazing policy and practice: Environmental and social impacts in three communal areas of Southern Africa. Environ. Sci. Policy 2006, 9, 302–316, doi:10.1016/j.envsci.2005.11.009.
[53]
Glantz, M.H. Draught and Hunger in Africa: Denying Famine a Future; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 1987; pp. 8–9.
[54]
Westoby, M.; Walker, B.; Noy-meir, I. Opportunistic management for rangelands not at equilibrium. J. Range Manag. 1989, 42, 266–274, doi:10.2307/3899492.
[55]
Vetter, S. Rangelands at equilibrium and non-equilibrium: Recent developments in the debate. J. Arid Environ. 2005, 62, 321–341, doi:10.1016/j.jaridenv.2004.11.015.
[56]
White, L.D.; McGinty, A. Stocking Rate Decisions—Key to Successful Ranch; Texas Agricultural Extension Service, Texas A&M University System: San Angelo, TX, USA, 1999; p. 11.
[57]
Tripp, R. Is low external input technology contributing to sustainable agricultural development? Nat. Resour. Perspect. 2006, 102, 4.
[58]
Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO). International Code of Conduct on the Distribution and Use of Pesticides. In Proceedings of the 123rd Session of the FAO Council, Rome, Italy, 26–27 November 2003; p. 6.
[59]
Wilson, R.H.; Charry, A.A.; Kemp, D.R. Performance indicators and benchmarking in Australian Agriculture: Synthesis and Perspectives; Schools of Accounting and Rural Management, Charles Sturt University: Orange, NSW, Australia, 2005; pp. 45–52.
[60]
Yesuf, M.; Bluffstone, R. Poverty, risk aversion and path dependence in low income countries: Experimental evidence from Ethiopia. Am. J. Agric. Econ. 2009, 91, 1022–1037, doi:10.1111/j.1467-8276.2009.01307.x.
[61]
Fafchamps, M.; Lund, S. Risk-sharing networks in rural Philippines. Dev. Econ. 2003, 71, 261–287, doi:10.1016/S0304-3878(03)00029-4.
[62]
Chetty, R.; Looney, A. Consumption smoothing and the welfare consequences of social insurance in developing economies. J. Public Econ. 2006, 90, 2351–2356, doi:10.1016/j.jpubeco.2006.07.002.
[63]
Abdulahi, M. The legal status of the communal land holding system in Ethiopia: The case of pastoral communities. Int. J. Minor. Group Right. 2007, 14, 85–125, doi:10.1163/138548707X181566.
[64]
Hardin, G. The tragedy of the Commons. Science 1968, 162, 1243–1248, doi:10.1126/science.162.3859.1243.
[65]
Ostrom, E. Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK/New York, NY, USA, 1990; pp. 1–11.
[66]
Food and Agricultural Organisation (FAO). Land Tenure and Rural Development. In FAO Land Tenure Studies 3; FAO: Rome, Italy, 2002; pp. 7–18.
[67]
Besley, T. Property rights and investment incentives: Theory and evidence from Ghana. J. Polit. Econ. 1995, 103, 903–937.
[68]
Food and Agricultural Organisation (FAO)/Government Cooperative Programme. Improving Information on Women’s Contributions to Agricultural Production for Gender Sensitive Planning. Project Findings and Recommendations; FAO: Rome, Italy, 1998; pp. 1–10.
[69]
Brklacich, M.; Bryant, C.R.; Smith, B. Review and appraisal of concept of sustainable food production systems. Environ. Manag. 1991, 15, 1–14, doi:10.1007/BF02393834.
[70]
Lorenz, M.O. Methods of measuring the concentration of wealth. J. Am. Stat. Assoc. 1905, 9, 209–217.
[71]
Shephard, A. Inequality under the Labor Government; Briefing Note No 33; The Institute for Fiscal Studies, March 2003. March 2003. Available online: http://www.duncanwil.co.uk/lorenz1.html (accessed on 16 August 2012).
[72]
Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO). Chapter 3. Land Suitability Classifications. In A Framework for Land Evaluation; Soils Bulletin 32; FAO: Rome, Italy, 1976.
[73]
Franco, J.A.; Gaspar, P.; Mesias, F.J. Economic analysis of scenarios for the sustainability of extensive livestock farming in Spain under CAP. Ecol. Econ. 2012, 74, 120–129, doi:10.1016/j.ecolecon.2011.12.004.
[74]
Masera, O.; Astier, S.; López-Ridaura, S. Sustentabilidad y Manejo de los Recursos Naturales. El Marco de Evaluación MESMIS; Mundi-Prensa: Mexico City, México, 2000.
[75]
Feeny, D.; Berkes, F.; McCay, B.J.; Acheson, J.M. The tragedy of the commons twenty-two years later. Hum. Ecol. 1990, 18, 1–19, doi:10.1007/BF00889070.
[76]
Ayatunde, A.A.; Leeuw, D.J.; Turner, M.D.; Said, M. Challenges of assessing the sustainability of (agro)-pastoral systems. Assess. Sustain. Dev. Anim. Prod. Syst. 2011, 139, 30–43.
[77]
Deininger, K. Executive Summary—Chapter 1 and 2. Introduction and Property Rights to Land. In Land Policies for Growth and Poverty Reduction; World Bank and Oxford University Press: Washington, DC, USA, 2003; pp. 1–76.
[78]
Kanji, N.; Cotula, L.; Hilhorst, T.; Toulmin, C.; Witten, W. Can Land Registration Serve Poor and Marginalized Groups?; Summary Report; Securing Land Rights in Africa, Research Report I; Russell Press: Nottingham, UK, 2005; pp. 3–4.
[79]
de Wit, J.; Oldenbroek, J.K.; van Keulin, H.; Zwart, D. Criteria for sustainable livestock production: A proposal for implementation. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 1995, 53, 219–229, doi:10.1016/0167-8809(94)00579-4.
[80]
WVU Team Takes Interdisciplinary Approach to Study Climate Change’s Impact on Wetlands. Available online: http://wvutoday.wvu.edu/n/2012/03/22/wvu-team-takes-interdisciplinary-approach-to-study-climate-change-s-impact-on-wetlands (accessed on 2 November 2012).
[81]
Steffey, K. Chapter 8. Insect Pest Management for Livestock and Livestock Buildings. In Illinois Agricultural Pest Management Handbook; College of Agricultural, University of Illinois Extension: Champaign, IL, USA, 1999; pp. 131–167.
[82]
O’Cannor, J. Is Sustainable Capitalism Possible? Natural Causes. Essays on Ecological Marxism; Guilford Press: New York, USA, 1998.
[83]
How to feed a hungry world. Nature 2010, 466, 531–532, doi:10.1038/466531a.
