This paper will try to shed light on a very particular angle of Greek political geography after the end of the Asia Minor War. As a result of this conflict almost 1.3 million refugees fled to Greece and changed dramatically its political space. The traditional view among the scholars of the period promotes an “exceptionalism” of the Greek-Orthodox refugees who fled to Greece after 1922. It is argued that the Asia Minor workers did not largely espouse an a priori notion of class, since they had a bourgeoisie economic and social background. However, in the 1930s there was a sharp increase in the support of the Left. Accordingly, the Communist Party pulled 5.76% of the vote, which was the highest in the inter-war period. Although the percentage of the communist vote was not so high all over Greece, Communism had a real electorate appeal for urban refugees. This study will challenge the exceptionalist perspective and will investigate why the same people who voted for Liberals in the 1920s voted for Communists in the 1930s. It will also examine how the Greek political system managed to incorporate the left-wing vote by transforming the division of society from labour and political demands to national ones in the period under examination. The focus will be also on the interplay between Communism and refugees, which is undervalued by most research on the topic, even though the communist threat was used as a reason or pretext for the abolition of parliamentary democracy and the establishment of Ioannis Metaxas’ dictatorship in 1936.
References
[1]
Statistical Annual of Greece; National Printing-Office: Athens, Greece, 1931.
[2]
Microfilms’ Archive of the European University Institute, Florence, Italy (EUI hereafter), League of Nations, Official Journal, 5th Year, 3rd Meeting. In The Settlement of Greek Refugees; Geneva, Switzerland, 1924; pp. 508–510.
[3]
Clogg, R. A Concise History of Greece; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 1992.
[4]
Marrus, M. The Unwanted; European Refugees in the Twentieth Century; Oxford University Press: Oxford, UK, 1985.
[5]
Zolberg, A.R.; Suhrke, A.; Aguayo, S. Escape from Violence: Conflict and the Refugee Crisis in the Developing World; Oxford University Press: Oxford, UK, 1992.
[6]
Betts, A. Forced Migration and Global Politics; Willey-Blackwell: Oxford, UK, 2009.
[7]
Veremis, T.; Dragoumis, M. Historical Dictionary of Greece; Scarecrow Press: Metuchen, NJ, USA, 1995.
[8]
Pentzopoulos, D. The Balkan Exchange of Populations and its Impact on Greece; C. Hurst & Co Publishers Ltd: London, UK, 2002.
[9]
Mavrogordatos, G. Stillborn Republic: Social Coalitions and Party Strategies in Greece,1922–1936; University of California Press: Berkley, CA, USA, 1983.
[10]
Karavas, S. Evolutions du comportement électoral dans l’agglomération d’Athènes (1926–1964). Ph.D. Thesis, Université Lumière in Lyon, Lyon, France, 1988.
[11]
Jelavich, B. History of the Balkans: Twentieth Century; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 1983; Volume 2.
[12]
Dakin, D. The Greek Struggle in Macedonia (1897–1913); Institute for Balkan Studies: Thessaloniki, Greece, 1993.
[13]
Schmitt, B.E. The Coming of the War, 1914; C. Scribner’s & Sons: New York, NY, USA, 1930; Volume 2.
Kitromilides, P.M. Imagined communities and the origins of the national question in the Balkans. Eur. Hist. Q. 1979, 19, 149–194, doi:10.1177/026569148901900203.
[16]
Smith, A.D. Chosen peoples: Why ethnic groups survive. ERS 1992, 15, 426–456.
[17]
Hobsbawm, E. Mass-producing Traditions: Europe 1870–1914. In The Invention of Traditions; Hobsbawm, E., Ranger, T., Eds.; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 1983; pp. 263–308.
[18]
Dockrill, M.L.; Douglas, G.J. Peace without Promise. Britain and the Peace Conferences, 1919–1923; Batsford Academic and Educational Ltd.: London, UK, 1981.
[19]
Morgenthau, H. I was Sent to Athens; Doubleday, Doran & Co: Garden City, NY, USA, 1929.
[20]
Hoare, S. Memorandum from the English MP Sir Samuel Hoare concerning refugee work. Templewood Papers; Part II, Box 4, File 8, Piece 38; Cambridge University Library: Cambridge, UK, 1922; p. 6.
[21]
Prosfygikos Cosmos [Refugee World], Athens, 10, August, 1933. Number of publication: 225, 1.
[22]
Giannakopoulos, G. Prosfygike Ellada: Photographies apo to Archeio tou Kentrou Mikrasiatikon Spoudon [Refugee Greece: Photographs from the Archive of the Centre for Asia Minor Studies]; Hidryma A.G. Leventi: Athens, Greece, 1992.
[23]
Mourelos, G. Martyries apo tes eparchies tis Kentrikes kai Notias Mikrasias [Evidences from the provinces of Central and South Asia Minor]; Centre of Asia Minor Studies: Athens, Greece, 1982; Volume 2.
[24]
Annual Report of 1926 on Greece. The National Archives of the United Kingdom [NA hereafter], Foreign Office [FO hereafter] 371/13659, C 45078; British Embassy: Athens, Greece, 1926; p. 22.
[25]
Ramsay, P. Annual report on Greece for 1929. NA, FO 371/14391, C 5972/5972/19; British Embassy: Athens, Greece, 1930; p. 2.
[26]
Efemeris ton Syzitiseon tis Voulis [Gazette of the Greek Parliamentary Debates (Gazette of the Debates hereafter)]; 39th Session; Library of the Greek Parliament: Athens, Greece, 1928. National Printing Office: Athens, Greece, 1930; p. 435.
[27]
Legg, K.R. Politics in Modern Greece; Stanford University Press: Stanford, UK, 1969.
[28]
Kazamias, A. Education and the Quest for Modernity in Turkey; George Allen & Unwin: London, UK, 1966.
[29]
Genika Archeia Kratous [General Archives of the Greek State] (G.A.K. hereafter). Manuscript file: 453, Protocol No. 7360. Community of Panormos, Prefecture of Kyzikos, Meeting: S, 29 April 1918; p. 237.
[30]
G.A.K.. Manuscript file: 453. Community of Panormos, Prefecture of Kyzikos, Meeting: I, 25 November 1918; p. 240.
[31]
Istoriko Archeio Ypourgeiou Exoterikon (IAYE hereafter) [Historical Archive of the Greek Foreign Office], Education in Dyrraheio, Asia Minor, Islands and various communities in Macedonia and Thrace. Education in Dyrraheio, Asia Minor, Islands and various communities in Macedonia and ThraceFile B/33: B Politics—Dimaras, C. (General Consular of Greece). Letter sent from the president of the school committee of the Evangelical School in Smyrna to 1914, 1–2,. (translated from Greek).
[32]
Straight, G. Letter from the Sub-Consulate of Greece in Vryoulais of Asia Minor to the Greek Minister of Foreign Affairs IAYE. File B: Section B. Protocol number: 10593; Sub-Consulate of Greece: Vryoulais, Ottoman Empire, 1914; pp. 1–2. (translated from Greek).
[33]
Salmon, B.P.; (Special Commissioner of the Minister of Public Assistance). Ministry of Welfare and Public Assistance. Report on the refugee situation in Greece. File 131; Archeio Eleftheriou Venizelou, Mouseio Benaki [Eleftherios Venizelos Archive, Benaki Museum] (Venizelos Archive hereafter): Athens, Greece, 1923; p. 1.
[34]
Vlavianos, H. The Metaxas Dictatorship: The Greek Communist Party under Siege. In The Metaxas Dictatorhsip: Aspects of Greece 1936–1940; Higham, R., Veremis, T., Eds.; ELIAMEP: Athens, Greece, 1993; pp. 103–226.
[35]
Pentzopoulos, D. The Balkan Exchange of Minorities and Its Impact upon Greece; The Hague Mouton: Paris, France, 1962.
[36]
Ramsay, P. Annual report on Greece for 1929. NA, FO 371/14391, C 5972/5972/19; British Embassy: Athens, Greece, 1930; p. 37.
[37]
Ramsay , P. Annual report of 1926 on Greece. NA, FO 371/11357, C 45078; British Embassy: Athens, Greece, 1926; p. 21.
[38]
Cheetham, M. Annual report of 1924 on Greece. NA, FO 371/10771, C 7036/7036/19; British Embassy, 1925; p. 22.
[39]
Andritsos, G. Report of the National Security Service to the General Army Staff. IAYE, File 5.1, no. 1004/298, Confidential, Protocol No. 22/34; Ministry of Foreign Affairs: Athens, Greece, 1927.
[40]
Papadopoulos. Report of the National Security Service to the General Army Staff Enclosing Copy of Document Signed by Confidential. IAYE, File 5.1: Protocol No. 22/29; Ministry of Foreign Affairs: Athens, Greece, 1927. (Translated from Greek).
[41]
Anthoules, I. Report of the Public Security and Gendarmerie Headquarters sent to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the General Army Staff. IAYE, File: 5.1, Confidential. Protocol No. 22/9; Ministry of Foreign Affairs: Athens, Greece, 1927. (Translated from Greek).
[42]
Tamiolakes, C. Preliminary investigation. Venizelos’ Archive, File: 86; Ministry of War: Athens, Greece, 1926.
[43]
Gazette of the Debates; 29th Session; Library of the Greek Parliament: Athens, Greece, 1920. National Printing Office: Athens, Greece, 1920; pp. 459–465.
[44]
Ekklesia [Church]. Year 1, 22 September 1923, No. 17; Greek-Orthodox Church of Greece: Athens, 1923; p. 134.
[45]
Gazette of the Debates; 44th Session; Library of the Greek Parliament: Athens, Greece, 1927. National Printing Office: Athens, Greece, 1928; pp. 3, 11.
[46]
Fleischer, H. The National Liberation Front (EAM), 1941–1947: A Reassessment. In Greece at the Crossroads, the Civil War and Its Legacy; Iatrides, J.O., Wrigley, L., Eds.; The Pennsylvania State University Press: Pennsylvania, PA, USA, 1995; pp. 68–89.
[47]
Pavlowitch, S.K. A History of the Balkans, 1804–1945; Addison-Wesley Longman: London, UK, 1999.
[48]
Linardatos, S. Pos Ftasame stin 4e Augoustou [How We Reached the 4th of August]; Themelio: Athens, Greece, 1974.
[49]
Mavrogordatos, G.T. The 1940s between Past and Future. In Greece at the Crossroads, the Civil War and Its Legacy; Iatrides, J.O., Wrigley, L., Eds.; The Pennsylvania State University Press: Pennsylvania, PA, USA, 1995; pp. 31–47.
[50]
Cheetham, M. Memorandum on Greece. NA, FO 371/11357, C 7535/4520/19; British Embassy: Athens, Greece, 1926.
[51]
EUI; League of Nations. Records of Plenary Meetings 1923–1926. Verbatim Record of the seventh ordinary session of the Assembly of the League of Nations, Geneva, Switzerland, 21 September 1926. In Report of the Second Committee on the work of the Greek Refugee Settlement Commission (RSC); Cambridge University Library: Cambridge, UK, 1926; p. 3.
[52]
Ethniko Idryma Erevnon [National Research Centre]. Pallis’ Archive, File: 10. Macedonia and the Macedonians. A Historical Study by A.A. Pallis; London, UK, 1949; p. 8.
[53]
Gazette of the Debates; 190th Session; p. 223.
[54]
Gazette of the Debates; 96th Session; pp. 98–166.
[55]
Gazette of the Debates; 63rd Session; p. 479.
[56]
EUI; League of Nations; Official Journal; Twenty-fourth Session of the Council. Letter from the Bulgarian Government to the Secretary of League regarding the Bulgarian inhabitants of Western Thrace. Annex 494, 31, March, 1923, 642.
[57]
EUI; League of Nations; Official Journal. Records of the Fourth Assembly, Meetings of the Fifth Committee, Geneva, Switzerland, 1923. Annex 15, Document No. A. v.19.1923; Special Supplement 18, pp. 137–138.
[58]
EUI, League of Nations, Official Journal, Records of the Fourth Assembly. Report on the Work of the High Commission for Refugees, Presented by Dr. F.J. Nansen. Annex 5, VII, Document No A.10, 1923, 211–212.
[59]
Koliopoulos, I.S. Leilasia Fronematon: To Makedoniko Zetima stin Katechomeni Dytike Makedonia,1941–1944 [Sack of Convictions: The Macedonian Question in Occupied Western Macedonia,1941–1944]; Vanias: Thessalonike, Greece, 1994.
[60]
Mazower, M. Greece and the Inter-War Economic Crisis; Oxford University Press: New York, NY, USA, 1991.
[61]
Johnson, Letter addressed to James W. Verity at the Royal Colonial Institute in London, League of Nations Archives (LNA hereafter), Geneva, Switzerland. R 1763, 48/25485/254853, 1923.
[62]
Statistical Annual of Greece; National Printing-Office: Athens, Greece, 1930.
[63]
Ball, T.; Dagger, R. Political Ideologies and the Democratic Ideal; Harper Collins: New York, NY, USA, 1995.
[64]
Mazower, M. The refugees, the economic crisis and the collapse of Venizelist hegemony, 1929–1932. Deltion Kentrou Mikrasiatikon Spoudon [Bulletin of the Centre of Asia Minor Studies] 1992, 9, 119–134.
[65]
Howland, C.P. Greece and Her Refugees. Foreign Aff. 1926, 4, 612–623.
[66]
Leontidou, L. Polis tis Siopis: Ergatikos Epoikismos tis Athinas kai tou Pirea [Cities of Silence; Labour Settlement of Athens and Piraeus, 1909–1940]; ETBA: Athens, Greece, 1989.
[67]
Colonas, V. Housing and the Architectural Expression of the Asia Minor Greeks before and after 1923. In Crossing the Aegean: An Appraisal of the 1923 Compulsory Population Exchange between Greece and Turkey; Hirschon, R., Ed.; Berghahn Books: Oxford, UK, 2004; pp. 163–178.
[68]
Tompson, S. Suburbs of opportunity: The power of home for migrant women. In Metropolis Now; Gibson, K., Watson, S., Eds.; Pluto Press: Sydney, Australia, 1994; pp. 33–46.
[69]
Gizeli, V.D. Kenoniki Metaschematismi kai Proelefsi tis Kenonikes Katikias stin Elada (1920–1930) [Social Transformations and the Origins of the Social Residence in Greece (1920–1930)]; Epikerotita: Athens, Greece, 1984.
[70]
Moskof, K. Eisagogika stin istoria tou kinematos tis ergatikes taxis. Hi diamorfose tis ethnikes kai koinonikes syneidisis stin Ellada [Introductory to the history of the movement of the working class. The formation of national and social consciousness in Greece]; Kastaniotes: Athens, Greece, 1988.
[71]
Protonotarios, A. To Prosfygiko Provlima apo Istorikis, Nomikis kai Kratikis Apopseos [The Refugee Problem from a Historical, Legal and State Perspective]; Pyrsos: Athens, Greece, 1929.
[72]
Ladas, S.P. The Exchange of Minorities: Bulgaria, Greece and Turkey; Macmillan: New York, NY, USA, 1932.
[73]
Nansen, F. Report by on the refugee situation in Greece, part II. R 1761, 48/24722/2433728; LNA: Geneva, Switzerland, 1922; p. 9.
[74]
Dertilis, G. Koinonikos Metaschimatismos kai Stratiotikι Epemvasi, 1880–1909 [Social Reformation and Military Intervention, 1880–1909]; Exantas: Athens, Greece, 1985.
Dieterich, K. Hellenism in Asia Minor; Oxford University Press American Branch: New York, NY, USA, 1918. Translated from the German by Brown, C.N..
[77]
Stavrianos, L.S. The Balkans since 1453; C. Hurst & Co. Publishers Ltd: London, UK, 2000.
[78]
Gallagher, T. The Balkans since 1989: The Winding Retreat from National Communism. In Development in Central and East European Politics; White, S., Batt, J., Lewis, P.G., Eds.; Palgrave Macmillan: New York, NY, USA, 2003; pp. 74–91.
[79]
Campbell, J.K. Honour, Family and Patronage: A Study of Institutions and Moral Values in the Greek Mountain Community; Oxford University Press: Oxford, UK, 1964.
[80]
Kritikos, G. The agricultural settlement of refugees: A source of productive work and stability in Greece, 1923–1930. Agr. Hist. 2005, 79, 321–346, doi:10.1525/ah.2005.79.3.321.
[81]
Sarantis, T. Letter to the Minister Constantinos Gontikas. File: 3.5, Gontikas’ Archive, Archives of the Agricultural Bank of Greece, Athens, Greece, 1932, 1.
[82]
Gazette of the Debates, 67th Session, Library of the Greek ParliamentAthens, Greece27, June, , Printing Office “Cosmos”Athens, Greece, 509.
[83]
Gounaris, V.K. ‘Egnosmenon koinonikon phronimaton’ koinokikes kai alles opsis tou antikommunismou sti Makedonia [Of known social beliefs. Social and other aspects of anti-Communism in Macedonia]; Epikentro: Thessaloniki, Greece, 2005.
[84]
Nikolakopoulos, E. Hi eklogike epirroi tis communistikes Aristeras, 1936–1951—Synecheies kai asynechies [The electorate influence of the Communist Left, 1936–1951—Continuities and discontinuities]. In Hi Ellada ’36–49. Apo ti Diktatoria ston Emfylio. Tomis kai synechies, [Greece, 1936–49. From the dictatorship to the Civil war. Ruptures and continuities]; Fleischer, H., Ed.; Kastaniotis: Athens, Greece, 2003; pp. 223–234.
[85]
Gazette of the Debates; 51st Session; p. 801.
[86]
Leondaritis, G.B. To Elleniko Ergatiko Kinema kai to Astiko Kratos, 1910–1920 [The Greek Labour Movement and the Civil State, 1910–1920]. In Meletimata gyro apo to Venizelo kai tin epochi tu [Studies around Venizelos and his Era]; Veremis, T., Dimitrakopoulos, O., Eds.; Philippotis: Athens, Greece, 1980; pp. 49–84.
[87]
Gazette of the Debates, 28th Session, Library of the Greek ParliamentAthens, Greece21, January, 1920, National Printing OfficeAthens, Greece451.
[88]
Kyrkos, M.K. The Refugee Problem. Kathimerini 1935.
[89]
Dritsa, M. Prosfyges kai ekviomechanise [Refugees and Industrialisation]. In Eleftherios Venizelos: Kinonia, Oikonomia, Politike stin Epochi tou [Society, economy, policy in his epoch]; Veremis, T., Goulimi, G., Eds.; Gnosi: Athens, Greece, 1989; pp. 27–123.
[90]
Gallant, T.W. Modern Greece; Oxford University Press: New York, NY, USA, 2001.
[91]
Karavas, S. Hi prosfygike psyfos sto poleodomiko sygkrotema tis Athinas stin periodo tou Mesopolemou’ [The refugee vote in the urban agglomeration of Athens during the inter-war period]. Deltion Kentrou Mikrasiatikon Spoudon [Bulletin of the Centre of Asia Minor Studies] 1992, 9, 135–136.
[92]
Campbell, J.; Sherrard, P. Modern Greece; Ernst Benn: London, UK, 1968.
[93]
Giati hi prosfyges tha sas misesun [Why the refugees will hate you]. Prosfygikos Cosmos [Refugee World], Athens, 10, August, 1993. No. of publication 225, 1.
[94]
Kitroeff, A. The Greek Peasantry: From Dictatorship to Occupation. In Aspects of Greece 1936–1940. The Metaxas Dictatorhip; Higham, R., Veremis, T., Eds.; ELIAMEP—Vryonis Centre: Athens, Greece, 1993; pp. 63–84.
[95]
Woodhouse, C.M. Modern Greece, a Short History, 5th ed. ed.; Clays Ltd St Ives Plc: London, UK, 1991.
[96]
Nikolakopoulos, E. Atlas ton Ellenikon Vouleftikon Eklogon kai Demopsyfismaton,1936–1977 [Atlas of the Greek Parliamentary Elections and Plebiscites, 1936–1977]; National Centre of Social Research: Athens, Greece, 1994.
[97]
Ramsay, P. Economic and labour conditions in Greece in the district of Piraeus. NA, FO 371/14380, C 422/41/19; British Embassy: Athens, Greece, 1931; pp. 3–4. Report from P. Ramsay, (Athens) 16 January 1930.
[98]
Harvey, M. Confidential report on South-Eastern Europe. NA, FO 371/15232, C 3095/274/19; British Embassy: Athens, Greece, 1931. Confidential: Mr. Harvey to Mr. A. Henderson, Athens, Greece, 23 April 1931 (Received on 7 May 1931).
[99]
EUI, League of Nations, Official Journal, Nineteenth Quarterly Report of the Refugee Settlement Commission, Financial Situation, C 406. M. 126, Athens, 15 August 1928; Signed by the President of the RSC, Charles B. Eddy, pp. 1–23.
[100]
Gazette of the Debates; 4th Session; 1929; p. 91.
[101]
Gazette of the Debates; 76th Session; 1933; pp. 1564, 1571.
[102]
Hirschon, R. Heirs of the Greek Catastrophe: The Social Life of Asia Minor Refugees in Piraeus; Clarendon Press: Oxford, UK, 1989.
[103]
Tannenbaum, J. The Neighbourhood: A Socio-Psychological Analysis. Land Econ. 1948, 24, 358–359, doi:10.2307/3159288.
[104]
Yerolympos, A. Inter-war Town Planning and the Refugee Problem in Greece: Temporary solutions and long-term dysfunctions. In Crossing the Aegean: An Appraisal of the 1923 Compulsory Population Exchange between Greece and Turkey; Hirschon, R., Ed.; Berghahn Books: Oxford, UK, 2004; pp. 133–143.
[105]
Markham, V.R. Greece and the Refugees from Asia Minor. Fortnightly Review 1925.
[106]
Beaton, R. Folk Poetry of Modern Greece; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 1980.
[107]
Archeio Genikes Dioikesis Makedonias [Archive of the General Administration of Macedonia—AGAM hereafter]. File 68, Strictly confidential letter to the General Government of Thrace. Protocol No. 275, Alexandroupolis, 1925, 1–2.
[108]
Ramsay, P. Report on Greece. NA, FO 371/15240, C 4937/4668/19; British Embassy: Athens, Greece, 1931. Report from Ramsay, P. (Athens), 26 June 1931.
[109]
Ramsay , P. Report on Greece. NA, FO 371/15240, C 5773/4668/19; British Embassy: Athens, Greece, 1931. Report from Mr Ramsay, Athens, 1931.
[110]
Mackridge, P.; Yiannakakis, E. Introduction. In Ourselves and Others, The Development of a Greek Macedonia; Cultural Identity Since 1912; Mackridge, P., Yiannakakis, E., Eds.; Berg: Oxford, UK, 1997; pp. 1–13.
[111]
Gazette of the Debates; 104th Session; 1931; p. 786.
[112]
Livieratos, D. Koinonike Agones stin Ellada (1927–31). Apo tin katafronia se mia kenourgia avge [Social Struggles in Greece (1927–1931). From Contemption to a New Dawn]; Polites: Athens, Greece, 1987.
[113]
Kostopoulos, S. Hi amfilegomeni pentaetia. Hi poria tou KKE sta chronia 1936–1941 [The ambiguous five-year period. The progress of KKE during the years 1936–1941]; Stochastis: Athens, Greece, 1983.
[114]
Gazette of the Debates; 32nd Session; 1920; p. 547.
[115]
Gazette of the Debates; 20th Session; 1913; p. 297.
[116]
Gazette of the Debates; 175th Session; 1924; p. 941.
[117]
Gazette of the Debates; 2nd Session; 1924; p. 13.
[118]
Gazette of the Debates; 1st Session; 1929; p. 19.
[119]
Kritikos, G. Primary teaching in a non-standard language as a tool of social and national integration: The case of Greek vernacular (1923–1929). In Standard Languages and Language Standards: Greek Past and Present; Georgakopoulou, A., Silk, M., Eds.; Ashgate Publisher: London, UK, 2009; pp. 47–65.
