Self-compacting concretes (SCC): comparison of methods of dosage

the composition of a self-compacting concrete (scc) should be defined to fulfills a number of requirements, such as self-compactibility, strength and durability. this study aims to compare three methods of dosage for scc with local materials, so as to determine which one is the most economical and rational, thus assisting the executor in making a decision and enabling economic and technical feasibility for its application. the methods used in the experimental program were: nan su et al., which was developed in 2001 [1]; repette-melo, which was proposed in 2005 [2]; and tutikian & dal molin, which was developed in 2007 [3]. from the results obtained in the experimental program, it was observed that the method which presented the lowest cost and highest compressive strength at the ages of 7, 28 and 91 days was tutikian & dal molin, while the one which reached the lowest chloride ion penetration, best compactness and highest elasticity modulus was repette-melo. in tests carried out in the fresh state, all tested methods yielded mixtures which comply with the self-compactibility levels required by abnt nbr 15823:2010 [4].