Diferendos y coincidencias en torno a la obra de Fran？ois-Xavier Guerra (una réplica a Medófilo Medina Pineda)

the article carries out a critical review of medófilo medina pineda's article "en el bicentenario: consideraciones en torno al paradigma de fran？ois-xavier guerra sobre las 'revoluciones hispánicas'" ("the bicentennial: considerations on fran？ois-xavier guerra's paradigm regarding the 'hispanic revolutions'"), published in the anuario colombiano de historia social y de la cultura (january-june, 2010). the objective is to open up a debate on guerra's approach, which, despite the profound influence it has had on spanish-american historiography during the last two decades, has not yet been the object of serious discussion.